Skip to Content

Dealing with Difficult Tenants: When and How to Enforce Eviction Procedures

Becoming a landlord is often seen as a great investment opportunity, but managing tenants, especially difficult ones, can quickly turn your dream into a nightmare. For new landlords, navigating tenant conflicts and understanding when and how to enforce eviction procedures can be especially tricky. Mistakes in handling these situations can lead to legal issues, financial losses, and unnecessary stress.

In this post, we’ll cover common mistakes new landlords make when dealing with difficult tenants and offer practical tips to avoid these pitfalls. We’ll also dive into the eviction process and when it’s necessary to enforce it.

Common Mistakes New Landlords Make

1. Lack of Thorough Tenant Screening

One of the most common mistakes new landlords make is rushing the tenant screening process. It’s tempting to rent to the first person who shows interest in your property, especially when your rental is sitting vacant. But skipping proper screening can lead to bigger issues down the road.

Why it’s a mistake:

Bad tenants often display red flags, such as poor credit history, a criminal record, or past eviction cases. Failing to catch these early on can leave you with someone who doesn’t pay rent on time or damages your property.

Resolution Tip:

Always perform a thorough background check, including credit, criminal, and rental history. You can also ask for references from previous landlords and employers. Screening services are available online to make this easier and more reliable.

2. Unclear Lease Terms

Another rookie mistake is not having a solid, legally binding lease agreement that clearly outlines tenant expectations, rent payment dates, and consequences for non-compliance.

Why it’s a mistake:

An unclear or poorly written lease can lead to disputes over rent due dates, maintenance responsibilities, and other important issues. If tenants don’t know the rules, they are more likely to break them.

Resolution Tip:

Have a lawyer review your lease agreement to ensure it complies with state and local laws. Include specific clauses for things like late rent payments, property maintenance, and what will trigger an eviction notice. Make sure the tenant understands the lease before signing.

3. Delaying Action When Problems Arise

New landlords often hope that tenant problems will resolve on their own, but this usually just worsens the situation. Late rent, property damage, or noise complaints are often early warning signs that should be addressed immediately.

Why it’s a mistake:

Waiting too long to act can result in larger financial losses or escalate into more severe legal issues. Ignoring problems can also signal to tenants that they can get away with bad behavior.

Resolution Tip:

Address issues as soon as they arise. Start with a polite conversation and document everything in writing. If the tenant doesn’t comply, take the next steps outlined in your lease agreement, whether that’s issuing a formal warning or seeking legal advice.

4. Avoiding Confrontation

Many new landlords fear confrontation, which can lead to a passive approach when dealing with tenants. This often results in unresolved issues, allowing tenants to break the lease without facing consequences.

Why it’s a mistake:

Being too lenient can create an unhealthy power dynamic, where tenants feel they are in control of the rental terms. This can lead to missed rent payments, unauthorized guests, or even property neglect.

Resolution Tip:

It’s essential to remain professional and firm when dealing with tenant issues. Remember that you are running a business, and it’s not personal. Stay calm, communicate clearly, and follow the terms of your lease.

When to Enforce Eviction Procedures

Eviction is a last resort, but sometimes it’s necessary to protect your property and finances. Understanding when and how to evict a tenant is crucial for new landlords.

Common Reasons for Eviction

1. Non-Payment of Rent:

Consistently missing rent payments is the most common reason for eviction. If a tenant repeatedly fails to pay, you may have no choice but to begin the eviction process.

2. Lease Violations:

If the tenant breaks significant lease terms, such as having unauthorized pets, subletting without permission, or causing property damage, it could warrant eviction.

3. Illegal Activity:

If a tenant engages in illegal activities on the property, such as drug use or dealing, eviction should be enforced immediately for the safety and well-being of other tenants and neighbors.

4. Property Neglect:

While tenants are not responsible for major repairs, they are expected to maintain the property in a livable condition. Neglect or damage beyond normal wear and tear can be grounds for eviction.

How to Enforce Eviction Procedures

1. Review Local Laws

Eviction laws vary by state and locality, so it’s essential to understand the specific regulations in your area. Mistakes in the eviction process can result in delays or even legal penalties.

Resolution Tip:

Consult with a lawyer or local property management association to ensure you are following the correct legal process for your state. Most states require that you give a tenant a formal written notice before beginning eviction proceedings.

2. Give a Proper Notice

In most areas, you need to give the tenant a formal “Notice to Quit” or “Pay or Quit” before filing for eviction. This notice informs the tenant of the violation (like unpaid rent) and gives them a specified period to remedy the issue.

Resolution Tip:

Ensure that the notice is delivered in accordance with local laws (e.g., personally or via certified mail). Keep a copy of the notice for your records.

3. File for Eviction

If the tenant doesn’t comply with the notice, your next step is to file for eviction in your local court. This involves submitting a complaint and providing evidence of the tenant’s non-compliance (e.g., unpaid rent, photos of property damage).

Resolution Tip:

Keep detailed documentation of the tenant’s violations, including any communication, notices, and proof of unpaid rent or damages. This will help strengthen your case in court.

4. Attend the Court Hearing

Once you file for eviction, you will be given a court date. During the hearing, present your case and provide all necessary documentation. If the judge rules in your favor, they will issue a formal eviction order.

Resolution Tip:

Remain professional during the hearing and stick to the facts. Your goal is to show that the tenant violated the lease, and you followed the legal steps to enforce the eviction.

5. Coordinate the Move-Out

After receiving an eviction order, your tenant will be given a specific time frame to move out. If they refuse to leave, you may need to hire a sheriff or law enforcement officer to oversee the removal.

Resolution Tip:

While it’s rare, some tenants may refuse to leave after being evicted. Be prepared to follow through with law enforcement to ensure a smooth transition.

Take Control Early

Dealing with difficult tenants and enforcing eviction procedures can be daunting, especially for new landlords. By screening tenants carefully, maintaining clear lease agreements, and addressing problems promptly, you can avoid many common pitfalls. And when eviction becomes necessary, understanding the process and local laws will ensure you protect your property and avoid costly mistakes. Stay proactive, be firm, and remember: you’re running a business, and your property is your investment!

 

Here are five helpful resources for landlords in Maine dealing with tenant issues and eviction procedures:

  1. Maine Attorney General’s Office: Offers comprehensive information on landlord-tenant laws in Maine, including tenant rights, eviction procedures, and sample documents to guide the eviction process.
    Consumer Law Guide – Chapter 14.
  2. Maine Judicial Branch – Eviction Information: Provides step-by-step guidance on how to handle eviction proceedings legally in Maine, including filing instructions and court expectations.
    Maine Judicial Branch Eviction Guide.
  3. U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) – Maine Tenant Rights: Outlines tenant rights and landlord responsibilities in Maine, including links to legal assistance and resources for understanding Maine’s specific housing regulations.
    HUD Maine Tenant Rights.
  4. Pine Tree Legal Assistance: A nonprofit that provides legal assistance to low-income residents in Maine, covering tenant rights, eviction defense, and detailed guidance for landlords navigating disputes.
    Pine Tree Legal Assistance.
  5. Maine Legislature – Landlord and Tenant Law: Offers access to Maine’s landlord-tenant statutes, providing the legal foundation for understanding the eviction process and tenant rights.
    Maine Landlord-Tenant Law.

These resources will help ensure that landlords are informed and compliant with Maine’s regulations when dealing with difficult tenants and potential evictions.

We are pledged to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for the achievement of equal housing opportunity throughout the Nation. See Equal Housing Opportunity Statement for more information.

The Neighborly Done Right Promise

The Neighborly Done Right Promise ® delivered by Real Property Management, a proud Neighborly company

When it comes to finding the right property manager for your investment property, you want to know that they stand behind their work and get the job done right – the first time. At Real Property Management we have the expertise, technology, and systems to manage your property the right way. We work hard to optimize your return on investment while preserving your asset and giving you peace of mind. Our highly trained and skilled team works hard so you can be sure your property's management will be Done Right.

Canada excluded. Services performed by independently owned and operated franchises.

See Full Details